We are Not in this together.
As the number of new COVID 19 cases tops 7,000 for the second day running, Boris Johnson addresses the nation yet again. On a day where the Commons Speaker berated the Government for treating Parliament with contempt for pushing through COVID rules without consultation I am listening with increasing cynicism to yet another lecture from a PM I have no respect for whatsoever.
It is his 100th briefing in which yet again he reassures us we will all be fine as long as we stick together and do as we are told. Really? We Are Not In This Together. Literally as well as emotionally.
Today, with hospital admissions increasing by the week, the North East, the North West, half of Wales and Scotland, in all millions of people in the UK are under local lockdowns. Lockdowns, plural, because these vary by region and are so complicated the Prime Minister himself cannot get them right, forced to apologise yesterday for 'misspeaking' after giving erroneous advice.
Down South we are not yet in lockdown. We have only to remember the rule of 6, with all its exemptions and complexities. And ignore everyone else and everyone else's actions, as it is impossible to see the rule of 6 working anywhere. I make no judgement about that, I cannot tell why people do what they do. Ignorance, denial or carefully judged objective decision? Everyone makes their own choices. Whilst I absolutely despair and despise those who refuse to wear masks, that surely is a minor inconvenience for an undoubted gain, as for the rest, each to their own, given the utter and complete chaos caused by continually changing obscure and illogical rules.
Boris repeats yet again his mantra of 'common sense' , frankly the the only sentence he has uttered today that makes real sense.
In a telling admission of that undeniable and truly depressing fact that we're in this for the long term is the news that teaching unions are already urging the cancellation of NEXT YEARS examinations. Fair enough. Well, at least one section with enough sense to plan ahead and allow students to concentrate on learning without the continual distraction of uncertainty.
Because we are, alas, in this for the long term. Time and funds have been squandered, testing is in tatters, the economy is shattered as is any cohesion or continuity in society as a whole.
My journey feels endless today. I feel lost, unsure even where to start. There seems nowhere to go. We have made no progress since I begun this blog. The virus is as contagious, as deadly. There is no vaccine. The economy is dire. Education is a mess at every level. Before there was hope. There was trust. There was a rainbow uniting us . Now we are not in this together any more, what on earth lies ahead.
One post on social media has so much attention this week it justifies copying here in full. I do not endorse it nor in many ways do I agree with it, yet it does accurately sum up how disenfranchised so many of us feel. I too am mad, angry, deeply, deeply, depressed at the state of this country and I too now have no trust in our Government to keep me safe. This article summed up the breakdowns and divisions in society today.
Zoe Clews, via Facebook:
I thought long and hard about writing this post and I've been sitting on it for days. I know it may cost me friends. It may cost me business. But I’ve come to realise those things aren’t
worth a damn if we don’t have our freedom.
This is a long post. I make no apology for it. I hope you will take the time to read it, but my bigger hope is that it will prompt you to take pause and to think about what is important in your own life, even if that puts you in a different place to the one I have reached.
At the end of March, when we were told to go into lockdown, almost all of us did so willingly. People were dying from Covid-related illness in terrifying numbers, and there was a clear imperative to do something significant to turn the tide of the virus.
In those months, I nearly lost everything I had spent 18 years building. The losses amounted to tens of thousands of pounds. But I understood it was necessary, and what is money
anyway when it is balanced against a human life? Nothing.
The threat was obvious, and the response – untested as it was – seemed proportionate and appropriate.
It no longer feels that way. Today, British life feels like one of suppression and oppression; one in which our civil liberties are being rapidly and deliberately eroded in the name of
something else.
My contempt for this Government is almost limitless, but this is not a post that rails against party politics. It is one that simply asks you to question whether the attacks on our civil liberty are justified by science. It asks you to make a decision about whether the concession of your civil rights that you are
now required BY LAW to make are worth the social and economic damage we will inflict on the whole of our society – rich or poor, black or white, old or young.
Neither am I a Covid-denier. Whilst I don't know anyone personally who has died or suffered, I do know several who have had it and are now doing well. The virus is real. The
response of our government is not.
Without a single exception, everyone I have spoken to believes the new restrictions are illogical, that they make no rational sense. Not one single person believes the science has
been proven. In fact, there is open conflict publicly among senior scientists and government advisers about how the virus will or won’t spread. Boris Johnson mumbles about the restrictions being a ‘circuit break’. That simply doesn’t
add up. All around the country, thousands of young people are sent back to school to mix in year
groups of 200 or more.
Children are not immune to the virus, they are carriers. Yet Johnson is perfectly happy to send each and everyone of them home every day to older, perhaps more vulnerable people.
How does this break the circuit?
Covid cases in schools have quadrupled in the last week and 1,300 of the 32,770 schools in the UK report they are not fully open due to the disease. Under the ‘rule of 6’ an infected child who may not display any symptoms can happily infect
five other people today. Those six people can each meet and infect 6 different people tomorrow. Now 36 people are infected. The next day it’s 216. The day after it’s 1,296. The
day after that it’s 7,776. On day six, that rises to 46,656. And by the end of the first week that one child has infected 279,936 people.
I ask you again, how does sending that child to school break the circuit? How does the rule of 6 break the circuit?
Hospitality businesses will now close at 10pm, but it’s okay for people to infect each other for the rest of the day. How does this break the circuit?
But we are silenced, as I have been until now, by the fear that to question the political motives behind the new restrictions is in some way selfish, or that healthy suspicion or
cynicism will be repurposed by others as the woo-woo ramblings of an unhinged conspiracy
theorist.
So, we hold our noses and we pretend we don’t smell the bullshit and we hand over our rights and freedoms to a government that has so far failed to offer any shred of evidence
that it has a single clue as to what it is doing or why it is doing it.
And I’ve had enough. To quote Albert Finney in the film Network, I’m mad as hell and I’m not going to take it anymore. It’s time to call bullshit on the abuse of power, on the invasion
of our privacy and liberty and on the questionable motives of a government that has seen its net approval rating drop an average of 7 points each of the last 5 weeks.
The government says hospital admissions are rising rapidly. Bullshit. Over the week to the Tuesday just gone, the number of new daily Covid admissions was relatively stable. On
Sunday, Monday and Tuesday the trend had slowed.
The government says it’s concerned about a rise in Covid-related deaths. Bullshit.
Statistically speaking, the death rate has been relatively stable since August 8 th . Yesterday there were 40 deaths. On April 20 the there were 1,172.
This government has failed to meet its testing targets. It has failed to implement a coherent track and trace strategy. Dominic Raab admits airport testing for Covid 19 will only identify
7% of those who have the virus. Matt Hancock warns students won’t be allowed home for Christmas.
And all the while respected virologists are also calling bullshit on the measures introduced
this week.
They ask why, if we’re experiencing a second spike, is it predominantly happening in regional areas rather than large metropolitan cities? The government has no answer.
They ask the government to disprove their argument that in fact it is now likely there is widespread herd immunity and that today’s relatively low hospitalisation and mortality rates amid high infection rates suggest that the virus poses a reducing threat. The government is silent.
No one questions the fact that the government’s top scientific adviser has £600,000 in shares in GSK and has made £5m from a Covid vaccine development. But if I so much suggest it’s in his and the government’s financial interest to suppress our
civil liberties until that (knocked up round the back of KFC rush job) vaccine is available, I’ve apparently gone la-la.
So, we allow them to continue to shovel their bullshit. We relinquish our power. The government hobbles the economy and borrows £30bn extra.
And we all shuffle a little closer to financial and emotional ruin.
I don’t care about leaving the pub early, or wearing a mask, or not going on holiday or only being able to see 7 of my mates. In that respect, the Covid measures are mildly inconvenient.
But I do care about the government using this situation to extend its covert surveillance, to extend its right of invasion of privacy, to extend the nature and level of personal data it
holds on every one of us, to extend its powers to silence free speech and the right to protest.
And I care about the further erosion of our civil rights that may be coming in the spurious name of protecting our health and safety.
I care about all THAT very much indeed. And I think you should, too.
You don't have to believe the Queen is a bloody Lizard or that Tom Hanks eats babies to think something is afoot right now. You simply have to have to scrutinise the facts and the
logic. It’s all out there.
Calling someone a conspiracy theorist because they suspect a government of not acting in the public interest or making up their rules on the back of a fag packet? That’s just a form of
gaslighting. It’s the same as telling someone they’re 'mad'; or carting Victorian women off to the asylum with a diagnosis of 'hysteria'; because they dared to disagree with their
husbands.
I’m not selfish. I’m not a 'Covidiot'. Telling people they’re ‘sheeple’ because you disagree them with is not helpful either btw, because all you do is drive everyone further into their trenches
I know this is uncomfortable for many of you to read. It's uncomfortable for me to write. But I simply cannot stand back and watch the unnecessary dismantling of thousands of lives
through a disproportionate and dictatorial government response without saying something.
I didn't come to this world to be scared and I didn't come here to not speak out. Neither did you. I’ve spoken to enough people to know many of you don't want to say anything because you’re afraid of what people will think of you, or the impact it will have on your business.
But free expression is your right and I urge you to be courageous and defend it. Our ancestors gave their lives for it.
And if you’ve got this far (thank you, by the way) and you believe that everything I’ve said makes me a "Conspiracy Theorist" then fashion me a tin-foil fedora quick-sharp, because I'm goddamn in.